Google cheats on Webmasters
As you might have noticed from my post the other day I was a bit ironic about Google Webmaster Tools thingy. It’s been noticed by many that even those highly publicized innovations like backlink checker are not working as even a simple Yahoo Site Explorer search like this one gives you much more links that are seen from Google webmaster tools. Now the hard proof emerged that Google is not only lame, but also is absolutely inadequate providing merely wrong information to webmasters. Just look at this screenshot:![]()
I was nearly blown off my chair when I first realized that according to this lzzr.com must be ranking first for the term Yahoo on Google. I must admit that my first thought was - thank God, my suffering is over, now I am the King of the web 2.0! And immediately after I was about to rush in panic to order a dedicated server and upgrade to a wider connection fearing lzzr.com in its current state would not stand the traffic explosion. Alas, there are no miracles in this world and I did not take me long to come back to reality and see that this simply can not be true ![]()
Now the questions are: If this isn’t in fact true than
- Why on earth Google is lying to me?
- What actually Google shows me?
The former one is easier to answer as it seems Google had become paranoid about disclosing even the smallest bit of info that might provide food for thought and help understanding their algos. I’ve mentioned already that Yahoo has a completely opposite policy: while Google becomes more and more secretive, they open as much as they can whuch is very helpful in daily SEO work.
The latter is a kind of nutter as I simply can not believe what I see and the only explaination for this I can find is that Google displays some kind of “microwawe-ready” results for ranking and the real ones go through an extensive cooking process before being served to the customer. I can only guess that at a certain stage in their SERP calculation lzzr.com indeed happened to rank first for Yahoo term (could it be due to my ingenious eSEO? LOL). I can even suspect that this might be so since I used a good old Yahoo regional domain seo trick but otherwise I have no clue as you don’t really think I am mad enough to optimize for Yahoo?
Ultimately, it all boils down to the fact that something is rotten in the kingdom of Google as it displays such crap and wants me to believe in it.
PS Nevertheless, how I wish it was true LOL!!!
tags: google webmaster tools, lzzr, seo, serp, yahoo, yahoo site explorer, cheat, eseo, hard proof, ironic, panic, paranoid, secretive, seo trick, traffic explosion, web 2.0
































From what I’ve been able to gather, the results under top search queries are for all searches at google, including google blog search. My guess is that at one point, somebody searched google blogsearch for yahoo and your site was #1 that moment.
I could be completely wrong though, that’s just my guess.
Comment by jeremy — February 18, 2007 @ 7:52 pm
Thanks for noticing this. Honestly, this never crossed my mind.
Although I doubt this is the case as I checked Google Blog Search for Yahoo an of course I am nowhere near the number one in results
Comment by LZZR — February 19, 2007 @ 1:02 pm
Looks indeed like you’ve been on #1 in one way; perhaps you’ve mentioned Yahoo somewhere on one of your pages? The only reason I could think of ;).
Comment by Leftblank — February 22, 2007 @ 2:54 pm
Google Provides completely inadequate backlink info…
It seems to be impossible to rank first on Google for Yahoo search term - not quite according to Google Webmaster tools. It persistently displayed my site lzzr.com ranking number one for Yahoo search term for over a week. Of cours the site was nowhere …
Trackback by Anonymous — March 8, 2007 @ 8:03 am
Something is rotten in Google, has always been!
Comment by Softwarebomber — August 26, 2007 @ 1:27 pm